Deferred Consideration in a Pre-Pack Sale: What Will an Evaluator Look At?

When buying a business or assets through a pre-pack administration, it’s not always possible to pay the full purchase price on completion.

A purchaser may offer an initial payment followed by instalments, or agree to make additional payments from future trading profits.

This is known as deferred consideration, and it can form part of a connected-party pre-pack administration sale.

However, where an Evaluator Report is required, the Evaluator will need to look beyond the total purchase price.

They will want to understand how much is being paid immediately, how much will be paid later, and whether there is sufficient evidence to support the purchaser's ability to make those future payments.

For example, a higher purchase price doesn’t necessarily mean a better offer if a significant proportion depends on uncertain future payments.

In this article, we explain how deferred consideration is assessed, what information an Evaluator may request and how purchasers can prepare for the process.

What is deferred consideration in a pre-pack sale?

Deferred consideration is simply the part of the purchase price that is paid after the sale has completed.

For example, a purchaser might agree to pay £150,000 for a business, with £75,000 payable immediately and the remaining £75,000 paid over the following 12 months.

Deferred consideration can take several forms, including:

  • Fixed monthly or quarterly instalments.

  • A lump sum payable at a later date.

  • Payments linked to future turnover or profits.

  • Additional payments triggered by agreed events or performance targets.

Payments linked to future performance are often referred to as earn-outs.

There is no general requirement under the Administration (Restrictions on Disposal etc. to Connected Persons) Regulations 2021 (ARR 2021) for the entire purchase price to be paid in cash on completion.

Deferred consideration is not necessarily problematic. .

However, the payment structure, the likelihood of receiving the money and the circumstances of the proposed sale are all relevant to the assessment.

Why does deferred consideration matter to an Evaluator?

Under ARR 2021, certain substantial disposals of a company's business or assets to connected persons during the first eight weeks of administration require either creditor approval or a qualifying independent Evaluator Report.

These Regulations apply in England, Wales and Scotland. Separate legislation applies in Northern Ireland.

Where the Evaluator Report route is used, the connected purchaser obtains the report and the administrator must consider it before deciding whether to proceed.

The Evaluator must provide an independent opinion on whether the consideration and the grounds for the proposed disposal are reasonable in the circumstances.

This means considering more than the headline purchase price.

For example, imagine two purchasers make the following offers for the same business:

Offer A: £250,000 paid in full on completion.

Offer B: £300,000, comprising £100,000 on completion and £200,000 payable over two years.

Offer B appears more attractive because the total purchase price is £50,000 higher.

However, £200,000 of that offer remains unpaid at completion.

Whether the deferred element represents reasonable value will depend on factors such as the purchaser's financial position, the payment arrangements, any security and the likelihood of the money being received.

This doesn’t mean Offer A is necessarily better.

It demonstrates why an Evaluator needs to understand the structure and supporting evidence behind an offer, rather than relying on the total figure alone.

The Evaluator is not responsible for selecting the successful purchaser. That remains a matter for the administrator.

What will an Evaluator look at when assessing deferred consideration?

Every transaction is different, and the information required will depend on the circumstances.

However, there are several areas an Evaluator is likely to consider.

1. The proposed payment terms

An Evaluator may ask:

  • How much is payable on completion?

  • How much is being deferred?

  • When are the deferred payments due?

  • Are the payments fixed or dependent on future performance?

  • Will interest be charged on the outstanding balance?

  • Are there any conditions that could reduce or delay payment?

  • What happens if the purchaser fails to pay?

These details should be clearly explained in the offer documentation, heads of terms or draft sale agreement.

Where different documents contain inconsistent figures or payment dates, clarification may be needed before the Evaluator can complete their assessment.

2. The purchaser's ability to make future payments

This is often one of the most important considerations.

Where deferred consideration is being funded from future trading, the Evaluator will want to understand whether the purchaser's financial forecasts support the proposed payments.

The Insolvency Service's official guidance specifically recognises that a viability statement or business plan is more likely to be requested where a proposed sale involves payments by instalments.

This helps the Evaluator assess whether the deferred consideration is reasonable and the purchaser's likely ability to pay.

Depending on the transaction, supporting information may include:

  • A business plan explaining how the purchaser intends to operate the business.

  • Cash flow forecasts covering the deferred payment period.

  • Details of the purchaser's available working capital.

  • Evidence of acquisition funding or financial support.

  • Forecast income and expenditure.

  • Details of existing borrowing and other financial commitments.

  • An explanation of the assumptions supporting future sales and profitability.

For example, if the purchaser proposes to pay £10,000 per month from future trading income, the Evaluator may need to understand whether the business is expected to generate sufficient cash after paying wages, rent, suppliers, tax and other operating costs.

A cash flow forecast cannot guarantee that future payments will be made.

However, it should provide a reasonable explanation of how the purchaser expects to meet those commitments.

The level of supporting evidence required will depend on the size, complexity and risk of the transaction.

3. Security for the deferred payments

Another important consideration is what protection may be available if the purchaser fails to make the agreed payments.

Depending on the circumstances, the transaction may include:

  • Security over specified assets.

  • A personal or corporate guarantee.

  • A retention or escrow arrangement.

  • Contractual rights following missed payments.

  • Other agreed protections for the unpaid purchase price.

ARR 2021 doesn’t prescribe a particular form of security for deferred consideration. However, the presence or absence of security may be relevant when assessing the proposed transaction.

For example, an offer involving deferred payments supported by valuable, enforceable security may present different risks from an unsecured offer relying entirely on future trading.

Security does not automatically make deferred consideration reasonable.

Its practical value depends on factors such as the assets involved, existing charges, priority and enforceability.

The legal effectiveness of any security arrangements should be considered by the transaction's legal advisers.

4. The valuation of the business or assets

The Evaluator will also consider the proposed consideration alongside the available valuation evidence.

This may include valuations of:

  • Plant, machinery and equipment.

  • Stock and other business assets.

  • Intellectual property.

  • Goodwill.

  • The business as a going concern.

Where part of the purchase price is deferred, the timing and uncertainty of those payments may affect how the overall offer is assessed.

For example, a proposed purchase price of £300,000 is not necessarily equivalent in practical terms to receiving £300,000 in cleared funds on completion.

The Evaluator may need to consider whether the value attributed to the deferred payments is supported by the available evidence.

5. Alternative offers and outcomes for creditors

The Evaluator may also need to understand why the proposed sale is considered reasonable when compared with other available options.

Relevant information might include:

  • Whether the business was marketed for sale.

  • Whether other offers were received.

  • The payment terms attached to competing offers.

  • The estimated outcome from selling assets separately.

  • The potential impact of closure on business value.

  • The likely financial outcome for creditors.

For example, an offer involving deferred consideration may still be commercially reasonable where alternative options would produce a lower overall recovery.

Equally, a higher headline offer may be less attractive if a substantial proportion is unlikely to be recovered.

The Evaluator will provide independent scrutiny of the proposed transaction.

The administrator remains responsible for deciding whether the sale should proceed, taking account of their statutory duties and the interests of creditors.

What if the deferred consideration depends on future profits?

Some pre-pack sales include additional payments linked to future business performance.

These arrangements are often described as earn-outs or contingent consideration.

For example, a purchaser may agree to pay an additional £50,000 if the acquired business achieves a specified level of turnover during the following year.

Unlike a fixed instalment, the additional payment may never become due.

An Evaluator may therefore need to understand:

  • How the payment is calculated.

  • What financial targets must be achieved.

  • The period over which performance will be measured.

  • Who controls the decisions affecting performance.

  • How the financial results will be verified.

  • Whether the payment is capped.

  • What happens if the parties disagree about the calculation.

The Evaluator Report must identify the nature of the consideration and its value in sterling.

Where the consideration includes a contingent element, the parties should be prepared to explain the value attributed to it and the evidence supporting that assessment.

A maximum potential payment should not automatically be treated as money that will be received.

The Evaluator must consider the available evidence and the circumstances of the proposed disposal.

What information should purchasers prepare?

Where a connected-party pre-pack offer includes deferred consideration, preparing the relevant information early can help avoid delays.

We would normally recommend having the following information available, as relevant:

  1. The full purchase price and payment schedule. Clearly identify the amount payable on completion and all subsequent payments.

  2. The proposed sale terms. Provide the offer letter, heads of terms or draft sale agreement, including any conditions or adjustments.

  3. A business plan and cash flow forecast. Explain how the purchaser intends to fund the deferred payments while meeting normal trading commitments.

  4. Evidence of funding. Include relevant bank statements, funding agreements, investor commitments or other supporting documents where available.

  5. Details of any security or guarantees. Explain the arrangements intended to protect the outstanding purchase price.

  6. Valuation and sale process information. Provide relevant asset valuations, marketing information and details of alternative offers where available.

  7. An explanation of any contingent payments. Set out the calculation, conditions and evidence supporting the amount attributed to them.

At Admin Eval, we work with purchasers and their advisers to identify the information needed for the particular transaction.

For a more detailed explanation, read our guide: What Information Is Needed for an Evaluator Report?

What can delay an Evaluator Report involving deferred consideration?

Pre-pack administration transactions often operate to tight deadlines.

Where deferred consideration is involved, delays can arise if the payment arrangements or supporting evidence are unclear.

Common issues include:

  • A headline purchase price that doesn’t distinguish immediate and deferred payments.

  • Different payment figures appearing in the offer and sale agreement.

  • Cash flow forecasts that don’t cover the full repayment period.

  • Insufficient evidence of the purchaser's funding.

  • Forecasts that rely on unrealistic or unexplained trading assumptions.

  • Security arrangements that have not been clearly documented.

  • Unclear conditions attached to contingent payments.

  • Changes to the proposed transaction after the evaluation has begun.

These issues may require additional information or clarification before the Evaluator can reach an independent opinion.

The earlier the payment structure is explained, the easier it is to identify any outstanding questions.

Our guide, How Long Does an Evaluator Report Take?, explains more about the process and the factors that can affect the timetable.

What happens if the deferred payment terms change after the report?

This is an important point for purchasers and their advisers.

An Evaluator Report must relate to the proposed disposal being completed.

Under regulation 6 of ARR 2021, a qualifying report must satisfy the requirement that there have been no material changes since the report was made to the property, the terms of the disposal or the circumstances relating to it.

Changes that may be material include:

  • A revised purchase price.

  • A significant change to the payment schedule.

  • A different amount of deferred consideration.

  • New conditions affecting whether payments become due.

  • Changes to the assets being acquired.

  • Material changes to the security supporting the payments.

Not every minor amendment will necessarily be material. However, where a material change has occurred, you unfortunately can’t rely on the existing report for the revised transaction.

If the Evaluator Report route is being used, a further qualifying report would be needed.

It’s important to keep the Evaluator and proposed administrator informed as the sale documents are finalised.

Frequently asked questions

Is deferred consideration allowed in a pre-pack administration sale?

Yes. However, where an Evaluator Report is required, the Evaluator must assess whether the consideration and grounds for the proposed disposal are reasonable in the circumstances.

The structure, timing and likelihood of receiving deferred payments may be relevant to that assessment.

Does deferred consideration have to be secured?

There’s no general requirement under ARR 2021 for deferred consideration to be supported by a particular form of security.

However, the availability and quality of security may be relevant to the assessment of the proposed transaction.

The administrator and transaction advisers should consider whether the proposed arrangements provide appropriate protection for the unpaid balance.

Can an Evaluator Report be started before the sale agreement is finalised?

Yes. An Evaluator can often begin reviewing the transaction while the sale documentation is being prepared.

However, the proposed terms must be sufficiently clear for the Evaluator to reach an independent opinion.

The final transaction must also remain consistent with the qualifying report, subject to the statutory requirements concerning material changes.

Does a favourable Evaluator Report guarantee that the sale will proceed?

No.

The Evaluator provides an independent opinion on the reasonableness of the proposed disposal.

The administrator must consider the report but is not bound by its conclusion.

The final decision about whether to proceed with the sale remains with the administrator.

What happens if the Evaluator is not satisfied with the deferred consideration?

If the Evaluator is not satisfied that the consideration and grounds for the proposed disposal are reasonable, the report must state this and explain the reasons.

This is known as a case not made opinion.

The administrator may still decide to proceed with the sale, but additional explanation and disclosure requirements apply.

For more information, read our guide: What Happens if an Evaluator Report Is Negative?

Speak to Admin Eval about deferred consideration in a pre-pack sale

If your proposed purchase includes instalments, an earn-out or another form of deferred consideration, it’s sensible to involve the Evaluator as early as possible.

At Admin Eval, we specialise in providing independent Evaluator Reports for connected-party administration sales.

We understand that pre-pack transactions are often urgent and that purchasers may be dealing with unfamiliar legal and financial requirements.

Our role is to explain what information is needed, identify potential gaps and provide an independent assessment in accordance with ARR 2021.

We work closely with directors, purchasers, insolvency practitioners and professional advisers to help the process progress efficiently while maintaining the independence required of an Evaluator.

If you’re considering a connected-party pre-pack purchase involving deferred consideration, contact Admin Eval to discuss your proposed transaction.

Or visit our Evaluator Report services page to learn more about how we can help.


Next
Next

Do You Need an Evaluator Report if the Sale Happens After the Administrator is Appointed?